Sunday, June 25, 2023

History, whether it chooses to repeat itself or not

 Considering the freakish outcome Yevgeny Prigozhin's armed rebellion has already produced (Prigozhin heading to "exile" in Belarus, Putin actually not killing him and somehow staying in power himself), Vladimir Putin might want to consider a history lesson:

 
On a previous occasion, there a major defeat of non-Soviet military forces caused massive political upheaval in an autocratic Russian government, and it was the Russo-Japanese War. What ultimately followed it was an abortive revolution in 1905, and although it was an abortive revolution it caused opponents of the Czarist regime (ranging from the Constitutional Democratic [i.e., Cadet] party to the Social Revolutionaries and the Bolshevik and Menshevik factions of the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party) to double down in their efforts to overthrow (or at least limit) the power of Czar Nicholas II. 
 
Another series of catastrophic failures against the German Army during World War I made things even worse, and although other factors were in play (severe social and economic inequity, the autocratic nature of the Czarist regime, you name it) those military defeats showed what a paper tiger the Russian Imperial army was. Could they suppress domestic dissent during peacetime? Of course. But could they do it after they were obliterated in military combat against the Deutsches Heer? Hardly. 
 
For a number of reasons I outlined above, Putin might be able to stay in power, but his seat behind his desk in the Kremlin is a lot less sturdy than it was in February 2022 when all of this started. And the only person he has to blame for that is himself.

Friday, January 6, 2023

A couple of reminders of a truly unpleasant event

Today is the second anniversary of the attempted self-coup on January 6th, 2001, and a couple of things you should read on it (provided you can find the time - one of them is quite lengthy, and the other isn't exactly a quick read, either) include the following:


The full text of the House January 6th Committee's report is available, but be forewarned: it's over 800 pages in length, and although you might want to read all the details it's going to take a good long time to actually finish it. 

RationalWiki's article on January 6th is shorter (but still extremely detailed) and has a good deal of appropriate snark that the official report had to avoid for the usual reasons. Either way, neither of these will let you forget what actually happened that day - which is precisely what the perpetrators, fellow travellers and apologists for the coup attempt don't want.

Newspaper of (W)rec(k)ord

 If you're a member of a conrunning organization, you know you're in serious trouble when the  Guardian  -  an internationally known...